Whereas the six Dutch islands in the Caribbean all have a (very) limited population size, analyses of political problems on the islands rarely seem to take the variable of state size into account. The available academic literature demonstrates that the population size of states has a strong influence on the quality of democratic governance, although scholars disagree on the question whether smallness is an asset or an obstacle to democratic development. After a discussion of this theoretical literature, the present article proceeds with a presentation of field research in three small island states (St. Kitts and Nevis, Seychelles, and Palau) in which the political consequences of a limited population size are analyzed. This analysis reveals that a number of size-related effects can be observed in all three examined island states, among which a tendency to personalistic competition, strong polarization between parties and politicians, particularistic relationships between voters and their representatives, and a dominant position of the political executive vis-à-vis other institutions. A subsequent analysis of the contemporary political situation on the Dutch Caribbean islands shows that the observed problems also play a role on these islands, which indicates that smallness is perhaps of greater significance than is now often supposed. |
Artikel |
Klein maar fijn?De effecten van kleinschaligheid op het karakter van politiek en democratie |
Tijdschrift | Beleid en Maatschappij, Aflevering 4 2013 |
Trefwoorden | State Size, Dutch Caribbean Islands, Democracy, Good Governance, Personalistic Politics |
Auteurs | Dr. Wouter Veenendaal |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Artikel |
Veranderend lokaal gezagDe gezagsbronnen van burgemeesters en wethouders verkend |
Tijdschrift | Beleid en Maatschappij, Aflevering 4 2013 |
Trefwoorden | authority, political leadership, mayors, aldermen |
Auteurs | Dr. Niels Karsten MSc MA en Drs. Thijs Jansen |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
The traditional authority of mayors and aldermen is readily challenged. Formal positions do no longer constitute authority. For that reason, new political repertoires are being sought after and are being developed by local political-executive leaders. This article analyses and compares the sources of authority for mayors and aldermen: how can they develop, maintain, and strengthen their authority? It develops an innovative typology of sources of authority. A distinction is made between institutional, positional, and personal sources of authority. The model is applied to the mayors and aldermen in relation to relevant socio-political developments that affect the two offices. It is found that the authority of mayors rests on institutional sources of authority more so than that of aldermen. For the latter, positional and personal sources of authority are more important. At the same time, personal sources of authority have become very important for mayors as well as aldermen. The results call upon mayors and aldermen’s skills and competences to develop personal authority through persuasion. |
Artikel |
Borging van het publiek belang in samenwerkingsverbandenDe rol van intermediairs bij de verlaging van de implementatiekosten van overheidsbeleid |
Tijdschrift | Beleid en Maatschappij, Aflevering 3 2013 |
Trefwoorden | public interest,, transaction costs, public private partnership, government information, intermediation |
Auteurs | Prof. dr. Frank Den Butter en Sjoerd Ten Wolde MSc S.A. |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
A public interest implies that government intervention is needed in order to enhance societal welfare. After the character of the public interest has been determined from the theoretical perspective of public economics, the government has the responsibility to safeguard the public interest at lowest societal costs. This article discusses the supportive role of intermediaries (or ‘middlemen’), using prescriptions from transaction management. A discussion of three case studies shows how in public private partnerships the knowledge of such intermediaries can be used in order to safeguard the public interest in an efficient manner. |
Artikel |
Groengasprojecten: energietransitie in ruraal Nederland? |
Tijdschrift | Beleid en Maatschappij, Aflevering 2 2013 |
Trefwoorden | green gas, Biogas, renewable energy, stakeholder analysis, climate policy |
Auteurs | Drs. Maurits Sanders en Dr. Thomas Hoppe |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
‘Green gas’ is a sustainable alternative to natural gas. It is produced by converting biomass into biogas, which can consequently be upgraded to natural gas standards. Expectations about green gas are high. According to the long term vision of Netbeheer Nederland, the representative association of gas grid operators, green gas will entail 50 percent of the domestic gas mixture by 2050. In line with this vision national government has adopted a green gas innovation support program. Production of green gas takes place in rural areas with abundant supply of organic production resources, especially manure. It is in demonstration projects that green gas niche development is to be proven. In this paper the central question is how green gas demonstration projects manifest at the local level. By conducting a stakeholder analysis, we take a ‘bottom-up’ research approach, which helps us to identify organizational and institutional barriers key local stakeholders have in relation to green gas demonstration projects. We judge this necessary to further understanding in green gas niche development. The results of the analysis are used to advice policymakers about design and use of policy instruments which can help to solve these barriers. |
Artikel |
Burgers als trusteesParticipatie, informele vertegenwoordiging en representativiteit |
Tijdschrift | Beleid en Maatschappij, Aflevering 1 2013 |
Auteurs | Dr. Bas van Stokkom, Dr. Marcel Becker en Teun Eikenaar MA MSc |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
The involvement of citizens in discussions about policy arrangements has been growing in the past decades. These forums of decision-making often provoke criticism because of a so-called ‘lack of representativeness’. Often a small group of active citizens takes the lead and decides which problems have to be dealt with. Some active residents primarily focus on improving the neighbourhood, regardless of whether their activities have everyone’s consent. This raises many questions related their representativeness. Do these participants form an adequate cross-section of the population? Are they speaking on behalf of others? Maybe passive citizens feel fine with the opinions of active citizens and agree that a small group of citizens is taking the lead. In this paper these active citizens are viewed as ‘trustees’: informal representatives who take responsibility to look after the neighbourhood’s interests, expecting that passive residents would support their efforts. The paper has two central questions: First, which ideas do active participants have about representation and representativeness? Second, in what respects can active citizens be characterized as ‘trustees’? In the theoretical part we contend that the notion ‘trustee’ may function as a theoretical framework to understand present-day citizen participation. In local policy networks many informal representatives express views and interests that are recognizable for many citizens. They are trusted, as long as their activities can be checked. The second part of the paper focuses on three projects of citizen decision-making within local safety policies (The Dutch cities Amsterdam, Deventer and Rotterdam). Within these projects, participants prioritize what kinds of activities and interventions police officers and other frontline workers should carry out. A main finding is that many active citizens function as contact persons who are continuously available for other residents. They do not wish to speak ‘on behalf’ of others but they are bestowed – often reluctantly – with the role of representative, as they demonstratively express neighborhood interests (‘clean, intact and safe’). Their reputation seems to be decisive. |