This article addresses the question how aldermen are selected and nominated and how this process is related to a number of democratic values like popular influence and transparency. The central question is how one becomes an alderman in the Netherlands. To answer this central question a document analysis has been carried out and 137 interviews with aldermen have been held in 77 municipalities that were selected on geographical dispersion and number of inhabitants. The research shows that the process until the appointment of aldermen is little transparent and democratic for the outside world. In the large majority of the cases aldermen are asked an nominated from within a political party. The road to becoming an alderman is not closed, in principle everyone can become an alderman, but it is also not transparent and accessible for everyone. For this the selection and nomination is too much tied up to and decided in political party networks. However, gradually changes occur in this closed party bastion, because now parties more often are forced to look for suitable candidates outside the party. |
Artikel |
Hoe word je wethouder? Een onderzoek naar de transparantie en het democratisch gehalte van de wethoudersvoordrachtEen onderzoek naar de transparantie en het democratisch gehalte van de wethoudersvoordracht |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurs­wetenschappen, Aflevering 2 2014 |
Auteurs | Julien van Ostaaijen |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Artikel |
Uitvoeringskracht in sociale wijkteams: een beproefd concept in een nieuwe context |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurs­wetenschappen, Aflevering 2 2014 |
Auteurs | Mirjan Oude Vrielink, Lydia Sterrenberg en Helga Koper |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In the Netherlands at January 1st 2015 municipalities will most likely receive administrative and financial responsibility for work, youth and societal support. Anticipating this change almost all large municipalities have introduced social neighbourhood teams, inspired by the successful model of the ‘Achter-de-Voordeur-aanpak’ (Dutch for ‘Behind the Front Door-approach’). In this article the authors reflect on this development, because of criticisms about the vagueness surrounding the social teams and with its further development in mind. In a historical analysis they look at this phenomenon in relation to its political and policy context. The central research question is the change in vision that has occurred since the first experiments with neighbourhood social teams and the implications for their design. The authors show how the focus in the policy discourse has gradually moved to arguments concerning the efficiency of the societal support, more self-responsibility and self-direction and more participation in the society and the labour process. This makes a different model for neighbourhood teams desirable, especially in terms of (1) the target group of the approach, (2) the depth of the support and (3) the role of the generalist and the room for manoeuvre or the powers this generalist receives. A lot of municipalities choose to discover gradually what works. Next to the time pressure this might explain the vagueness of the plans for the design and organization of neighbourhood teams. |
Artikel |
Strategie, structuur en samenleving: drie dimensies van regionale uitvoeringskracht |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurs­wetenschappen, Aflevering 2 2014 |
Auteurs | Marcel Boogers |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Nowadays municipalities in the Netherlands work together more intensively with other municipalities in the region. Also cooperation with companies, institutions and societal organizations is more often looked for at the regional level. In practice this brings along many problems and difficulties. For several reasons it appears not to be easy to combine the implementation strengths of municipalities and societal partners. This article presents a new approach (based on the theory of ‘new regionalism’) to regional implementation strength. This approach is not only about designing regional administrations, but is mainly about the factors that induce administrations as well as companies and institutions to commit themselves jointly for the region. To increase the regional implementation strength more is needed than the formation of a regional administrative structure in which municipalities do not cooperate in a non-committal manner. To induce municipalities and societal partners to commit themselves jointly to handling new tasks or new challenges it is also necessary to have a clear strategic vision on these issues that binds parties and makes them enthusiastic and that regional cooperation is rooted in a societal breeding ground. It also asks for an administrative structure that does justice to the contribution every municipality and societal partner makes to the realization of the strategy and for a democratic involvement of municipal councils and sector-based interest groups. |
Artikel |
De zoektocht naar goed bestuurEen analyse van botsende waarden in de publieke sector |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurs­wetenschappen, Aflevering 2 2014 |
Auteurs | Remco Smulders, Gjalt de Graaf en Leo Huberts |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In the public as well as the semi-public sector numerous codes of good governance have been written. Although theses codes clearly lay down which public values must be the foundation of our administration, our newspapers often show examples of bad governance. It is striking that these codes mostly just picture an ideal, but do not give insight in tough considerations. In this article the authors show that different public values mentioned in codes are all worth pursuing as such, but that they in practice collide with each other. The manner in which administrators, managers and executives cope with such dilemmas, determines public opinion on good governance. Two cases have been researched: a municipality and a hospital. Through a Q-research six value patterns are demonstrated to exist in these cases. In addition (through interviews) the authors have discovered which values exactly collide in the cases, and which strategies are used to cope with collisions of values. |
Artikel |
What the frack?Politiserende deliberatie in de besluitvorming over schaliegas |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 2 2014 |
Trefwoorden | wicked problems, shale gas, hydraulic fracturing, deliberation |
Auteurs | Tamara Metze |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Within the past two years, hydraulic fracturing for shale gas became a highly contested technology in the Netherlands. Possible negative environmental impacts are at strained terms with possible economic, energy and geo-political benefits. In addition, there are many scientific uncertainties about, for example water contamination, methane emissions, the amounts of gas to extract and the risk of earth quakes. Societal conflict and scientific uncertainties make fracking for shale gas a wicked problem for decision makers. This article demonstrates that the Dutch Ministry of Economic Affairs has implemented several instruments for deliberation, such as a consultation round with stakeholders and a sound board for an independent research. These failed to lead to the desired support for fracking. In this contribution, I demonstrate that these instruments led to reason giving but not to structuring of the problem. They were used by governmental actors and protest groups as a political platform that was fuel for the political conflict. |
Artikel |
Wie is hier onredelijk!?Een analyse van de maatschappelijke dynamiek rondom de HPV-vaccinatiecampagne |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 2 2014 |
Trefwoorden | scientific advice, vaccination, well-ordered science |
Auteurs | Albert Meijer, Paulus Lips en Huub Dijstelbloem |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
This article presents an analysis of the introduction of the HPV vaccine into the National Vaccination Program in the Netherlands. This introduction resulted in public debate and resistance and eventually a low turn-out (45% while 85% was expected). The question is what we can learn from this specific case about trust of citizens in scientific advice and political decision-making around medical issues. Our qualitative empirical research highlights that trust in scientific advice was undermined by a combination of criticism from peers, a critical approach in the mass media and a strong campaign through social media. Our analysis shows that these factors can be understood as partly resulting from a transition to a network society. We conclude that the network society demands a more open approach of scientific advice both in terms of who they discuss issues with and what kinds of arguments are permitted in the debate. |
Artikel |
Deliberatie over klimaatkennisDe publieke omgang van het PBL met IPCC-fouten en klimaatsceptici |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 2 2014 |
Trefwoorden | IPCC, ClimateDialogueorg, deliberative assessment, wicked problems |
Auteurs | Willemijn Tuinstra en Maarten Hajer |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Climate change is often referred to as exemplary for ‘wicked’ problems. Wicked problems are referred to in literature as being inherently political problems without a clear definition or solution for which top-down steering using scientific knowledge is not fitting. Paradoxically, international climate change policy is organized in a quite top down manner in which scientific findings have a prominent role. In this paper we explore the effects of a deliberative approach to knowledge generation. We discuss two cases: an assessment of the credibility of the 2007 Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) reports and the organization of a scientific dialogue on internet. |
Artikel |
Zorgen over zendmasten: hoe een maatschappelijk debat verengd wordt tot de definiëring van gezondheidsrisico’s |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 2 2014 |
Trefwoorden | wicked problems, mobile phone, policy controversy |
Auteurs | Marijke Hermans, Marjolein van Asselt en Wim Passchier |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Concerns about mobile phone masts are often put down as unfounded fears of health risks. However, our ethnographic study of mast siting controversies shows that citizens mostly want to be democratically involved in the siting decisions. There is no room for such engagement in the national antenna policy, thus, citizens shift their attention to the possibility of health risks. The national government responds to this with more research and risk communication. However, the centrality of science leads to a shift in the discussion towards the credibility of science. Even a Klankbordgroep (Sounding Board) with all stakeholders fails to change the focus. This article shows that local conflicts are not so much the result of individual concerns, which is the subject of many social sciences studies, but are the outcome of a dynamic interaction between governments, citizens and scientists. Governments should not frame a local issue only in terms of a scientific problem. |
Artikel |
Politiek, participatie en experts in de besluitvorming over super wicked problems |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 2 2014 |
Trefwoorden | wicked problems, scientific knowledge, social engineering, deliberative democracy |
Auteurs | Tamara Metze en Esther Turnhout |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
This special issue focusses on deliberative elements in deciding over wicked problems. We present four case studies in which some form of deliberation was organized: the placement of mobile phone masts, hydraulic fracturing for shale gas, the failed HPV vaccination campaign and climate dialogues organized to enhance deliberative knowledge production over climate change. The case studies demonstrate how each of the deliberative processes has become politicized and that deliberative governance runs the risk of turning into a technocratic policy approach. |
Artikel |
Uitleiding |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 2 2014 |
Trefwoorden | wicked problems |
Auteurs | Roel in ’t Veld |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
This article draws several conclusions based on the case studies featured in this special issue. It places them amidst broader developments in public administration theory and practice, formulates several lessons and describes possible paths for future research. |
Artikel |
Groeiend ongemakBestuurderspartijen en de constructie van het vertrouwen in de overheid |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 2 2014 |
Trefwoorden | trust, political parties, party manifestos |
Auteurs | Thomas Schillemans en Paul den Otter |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Decreasing trust in government is almost universally considered to be a troubling fact of life for governments. Even though many politicians, administrators and commentators assume that the public’s trust in government is waning, the empirical data from the Netherlands are not unequivocal. This suggests that the assumed crisis of trust is not ‘just’ an empirical fact but is also to some extent a social construction. This article analyses how the major Dutch political parties have contributed to the narrative of a ‘failing government’. It does so by analysing their party programs over the last half century (95 programs in total). The analysis demonstrates that the major political parties are increasingly inconvenient with the effectiveness and efficiency of government, the traditional role of bureaucracies and the tasks of civil servants. This narrative harks back to the parties themselves and becomes increasingly inconvenient. If it is true that government fails to meet their standards, as they now all claim, what does that disclose about government policies for which those parties have been responsible? |
Artikel |
Verandermanagement en beleid: waarom vertonen professionals weerstand tegen nieuw beleid? |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 2 2014 |
Trefwoorden | public policy,, change management, policy implementation, public management, resistance to change |
Auteurs | Lars Tummers |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Professionals often have problems with governmental policies they have to implement. This can lead to diminished legitimacy and lower policy performance. The goal of this article is to identify the main reasons why professionals resist implementing new policies. An interdisciplinary approach is taken. From public administration literature, I use the policy alienation model, which consists of five dimensions: strategic, tactical and operational powerlessness, societal meaninglessness and client meaninglessness. These are possible reasons why professionals resist public policies (‘resistance to change’, a concept drawn from change management literature). I test these assumptions using a survey among 1,317 healthcare professionals. The results show that when professionals experience that a policy is meaningless for society or for their own clients, they show strong resistance. A lack of perceived influence is much less important in explaining resistance, although this is partly dependent on the particular profession someone belong to. The policy alienation model can help policy makers and managers to develop policies which are accepted by professionals. The article ends with practical recommendations for policy makers, managers and professionals. |
Artikel |
Over rijdende treinen en vallende dominostenen: het rookverbod in de Nederlandse horeca |
Tijdschrift | Beleid en Maatschappij, Aflevering 2 2014 |
Trefwoorden | smoking ban, regulation, support, effectiveness, explanations |
Auteurs | Dr. Heleen Weyers en Willem Bantema MSc |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In the near future, the Dutch government intends to change the rules relating to smoking bans in the hospitality industry again. After a complete ban, coming into force in July 2008, and introducing an exception for small bars in June 2011, the complete ban will return this year. This article describes the law regarding smoking bans in the Netherlands, and reports along researches of the relevant authority and a commercial research institute the effectiveness of the bans. From these findings it becomes clear that the hospitality industry did a good job in complying with the bans. But there is one exception: small bars. Next we explain, based on the ideas of Kagan and Skolnick and Elias the effectiveness of smoking bans. |
Artikel |
Het probleem van laaggeschooldheid in België: een historisch-geografische analyse |
Tijdschrift | Beleid en Maatschappij, Aflevering 2 2014 |
Trefwoorden | human capital, unskilled, school dropout, geographical segregation |
Auteurs | Drs. Frederik Van Der Gucht en Prof. dr. Raf Vanderstraeten |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
This article presents an analysis of the geographical clustering at the bottom end of the human capital distribution within Belgium and its major political regions (namely, the Flemish and the Walloon Region). At the national level, there is both a clear decrease of the shares of unskilled and unqualified adults and of their regionally unequal distribution. However, this overall decrease goes along with growing divergences between Flanders and Wallonia. In Flanders the number of early school leavers has become small. In Wallonia economic problems – measured in terms of unemployment rates – go hand in hand with a comparatively high number of school dropouts. Our empirical findings suggest that the success of particular areas and regions in a knowledge-intensive economy depends not only on the presence of highly skilled and highly qualified human capital, but also suffers from the presence of relatively large shares of the less-skilled. We discuss some implications for political decision-making. |
Artikel |
Het ongrijpbare onbehagen |
Tijdschrift | Beleid en Maatschappij, Aflevering 1 2014 |
Trefwoorden | Discontent, Public opinion, (Social) media, Democracy, Civil society |
Auteurs | Dr. Dieneke de Ruiter en Jasper Zuure MSc |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Since Pim Fortuyn, discontent has become a central issue in public and political debates in the Netherlands. The government tries to ban out all risks and polarisation between citizens, because it fears this will have a destabilising impact on society. However, these measures do not seem to decrease discontent. In this article, we analyse why discontent so persistently keeps dominating debates. We argue that it is prominently and continuously expressed due to the position of opinion polls and the interaction between politicians, journalists and citizens and due to the platform that social media offer. But meanwhile, means to convert discontent into constructive, collective action are diminishing. As a result we continuously gather superficial information about people’s discontent. In order not to hinder constructive debates with this kind of information, as happens in current political discussions, different and more detailed information about the public opinion is needed. Politicians and researchers should make a more clear distinction between discontent itself and the incapacity of citizens to deal with it. Moreover, a revitalisation of the role of civil organisations is important to channel discontent. |
Artikel |
De Collectieve Horeca Ontzegging: uitsluiting uit de publieke ruimte? |
Tijdschrift | Beleid en Maatschappij, Aflevering 1 2014 |
Trefwoorden | Responsibilization, Collective Pub Ban, Selective exclusion, Security, Public space |
Auteurs | Dr. mr. Marc Schuilenburg en Dr. Ronald van Steden |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
The article provides a theoretical and empirical analysis of the Night Time Economy and how the Collective Pub Ban is applied in three Dutch cities: Utrecht, Amersfoort and Den Bosch. The Collective Pub Ban is a measure taken in the Netherlands in an effort to make pubs, bars and clubs co-responsible for maintaining security. Depending on the severity of the conduct, an offender can be denied of entry to these venues for five years. During this period, the offender is not allowed to enter the particular pub or any of the other pubs, bars and clubs that participate in this measure. On the basis of 84 interviews, we show how these venues fill out their new responsibilities with respect to the Collective Pub Ban-measure. Also, we answer the question what this new measure means for the quality of the public space. |
Artikel |
De bestuurlijke organisatie in Nederland: spanningsvelden en veranderstrategieën |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 1 2014 |
Trefwoorden | nation state, structural reforms, decentralisation |
Auteurs | Cees Paardekooper en Harry ter Braak |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
The Dutch Minister for the Interior Ronald Plasterk has proposed far-reaching reforms for the structuring of the Dutch nation state. These reforms include decentralising tasks to municipalities and merging several provinces. So far, these plans have met with criticism and derision. This article discusses the tensions included in Plasterk’s plans and proposes several strategies for how change could still be possible. |
Artikel |
De grote verbouwingEen bestuurskundig perspectief op veranderingen in stelsels van publieke voorzieningen |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 1 2014 |
Trefwoorden | public management reform, New Public Management, New Public Governance |
Auteurs | Philip Marcel Karré en Cees Paardekooper |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
The Netherlands is engaged in reforming several of its public service provision sectors by limiting their hybrid (mixed public/private) character. This special issue deals with these reforms. We have a closer look at the systems of transport, education and housing, and also discuss reforms of the Dutch nation state. Each article poses three basic questions: why has the sector evolved as it has? Why is change seen as necessary? And how does this process take place? By doing so, we draw general lessons on how the Netherlands deals with system change and public management reform. |
Artikel |
Vastgeklonken aan de FyraEen pad-afhankelijkheidsanalyse van de onvermijdelijke keuze voor de falende flitstrein |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 1 2014 |
Trefwoorden | complex decision-making, high-speed railways, megaprojects, path-dependency |
Auteurs | Lasse Gerrits en Peter Marks |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In the spring of 2013, the Dutch railway operator, High Speed Alliance, cancelled the acceptance procedures for V250 high-speed train sets they ordered from Italian manufacturer AnsaldoBreda after numerous problems with the build quality and safety systems. It is the latest chapter in a series of failed attempts to build and run a high-speed railway link between Amsterdam and Paris. Inevitably, the question of who was responsible for the decision to order the V250 has become prominent. We study 20 years of public decision-making by analysing the content of over 1,200 documents. Using David’s and Arthur’s theory of path-dependency, we conclude that all the decisions that were taken during those two decades created a situation in which the choice for the V250 was nothing more than an inevitable gamble. It can therefore be concluded that all parties involved, from the railway operator to Parliament, have contributed to the current failure. |
Artikel |
Intergemeentelijk samenwerken: het kan ook lichtEen verkenning van lichte vormen van intergemeentelijke samenwerking |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 1 2014 |
Trefwoorden | inter-municipal cooperation, light forms of cooperation, modes of cooperation |
Auteurs | Leon van den Dool en Linze Schaap |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Many tasks will be decentralized to municipalities in the Netherlands in the coming years. To deal with these challenges, central government encourages municipal mergers, while municipalities often prefer a light form of cooperation. Since municipal boarders are converging less and less with the boarders inhabitants experience in their daily lives, municipalities feel free to cooperate in a variety of ways with other partners. This poses new challenges to democratic legitimacy, effectiveness and the role local authorities play. Local governments therefore do not need new regulations or legal forms of co-operations, but rather a repertoire fitting their role. We argue that local governments need to analyse their tasks, choose the form of cooperation that fits best and develop a repertoire for their cooperation. Light forms of cooperation are very important for developing a variety of cooperative forms and roles local governments need to play. |