Infrastructure and adjacent areas represent extensive social value. However, infrastructure and areas are still often developed sectoral and independent. In the Netherlands, national spatial policies strive for combining infrastructure and area as one integrated approach as this is expected to result in more spatial quality. Taking this perspective, this article discusses trendy concepts in current Dutch planning, such as: adaptive planning, public and private cooperation and challenge-oriented approaches (‘opgave-gericht werken’ which focuses less on realising a project but more on the current and future issues and challenges in an area). This article argues that these concepts are closely related. Adaptive planning defines the rules of the game and the playing field, within which cooperation may develop. Cooperation is a means for creating spatial quality in interaction within this playing field. After all, generated quality can be considered as a contribution to the specific objectives and interest of the various partners. A challenge-oriented approach is the process for generating spatial quality from synergies in combined infrastructure and spatial development. This article aims to explore the relationships between adaptive planning, public and private cooperation and challenge-oriented approaches and to provide starting points for further research and discussion. |
Artikel |
Van project naar opgaveSamenwerking als motor van de planning van infrastructuur en ruimte |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 4 2016 |
Trefwoorden | planning, cooperation, challenge-oriented approach, infrastructure and spatial development |
Auteurs | Wim Leendertse, Jos Arts, Tim Busscher e.a. |
Samenvatting |
Artikel |
Participant of databron?Burgers als extensie van stedelijk innovatievermogen |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 4 2016 |
Trefwoorden | data-driven innovation, cities, public participation, user innovation |
Auteurs | Albert Meijer, Zsuzsanna Tomor, Ank Michels e.a. |
Samenvatting |
In the private sector, user innovation is used to develop innovations that better fit the needs of customers. In the public sector, interest for citizen innovation is also on the rise and new information and communication technologies seem to offer a great potential for accessing the power of citizens. At the same time these technologies offer another potential value: they can turn citizens into data sources. This data can offer governments crucial insights and may form the basis for datadriven innovation. Innovating with citizens in both different ways seems to offer great potential for broadly supported issues such as urban sustainability. This article develops a framework for studying these new developments and presents explorative research in three cities (Curitiba, Glasgow en Utrecht). The research shows that cities make different choices in their use of new technologies to innovate with or for citizens. |
Artikel |
Hoe staat de lokale democratie in Nederland ervoor? |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurs­wetenschappen, Aflevering 4 2016 |
Auteurs | Prof. dr. Klaartje Peters en Drs. Vincent van Stipdonk |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Is local democracy in the Netherlands equipped for its mission? There is confusion and disagreement about the answer to this question. How people assess existing democratic practices is strongly influenced by one of the three main perspectives: representative democracy, participative (deliberative) democracy or ‘do-democracy’ (associative democracy). But to be able to have this discussion in the first place, empirical knowledge is required about the state of democracy at the local level. In this article (apart from the introduction, the first in a series on the local democratic audit) the authors bring together the available research data and organize these data with the help of David Easton’s system model: from input of citizens and civil society via throughput to output and finally feedback again in the political system. The research presented offers some insight in the state of local democracy, although it is not possible to give a final assessment. That depends on the perspective on democracy chosen, but it is also not possible because of the fragmented and incomplete nature of the research on local democracy in the Netherlands. The authors advocate contributing to these discussions with more empirical knowledge. The overview in this article shows that there is work to be done in this respect. |
Artikel |
De responsabilisering van burgers van verzorgingsstaat tot participatiesamenlevingDiscoursanalyse van troonredes en regeringsverklaringen sinds de jaren zestig |
Tijdschrift | Beleid en Maatschappij, Aflevering 4 2016 |
Trefwoorden | Participation society, Withdrawing government, Making-responsible citizens, Dutch speeches from the throne, Dutch government statements |
Auteurs | Ermy Brok MA |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Central concern of this article is tracing back how the making-responsible of citizens takes shape within Dutch speeches from the throne, government statements and reports of the Dutch Social and Cultural Research Institute (SCP) ever since the 1960s. The Dutch participation society, a term much discussed ever since mentioned in the 2013 speech of the throne, is often associated with a withdrawing government and a coming to end of the welfare state. At the same time, according to several authors, the notion of a withdrawing government that operates within a network of multiple equal actors has brought along the need for a widening of the government’s repertoire of action. This has been characterized as making-responsible citizens on conditions of the state. It has raised doubts about true government-withdrawal and authors have related it to the dominance of neo-liberal thinking ever since the 1990s. Applying an analysis framework derived from discourse analysis, it is made tangible in this article how within political discourse beginnings of the making-responsible of citizens can be traced to the 1960s, more than thirty years earlier than expected. It is argued that this longer history makes a plea for encouraging the political dimension of citizenship all the more important. |
Artikel |
|
Tijdschrift | Beleid en Maatschappij, Aflevering 4 2016 |
Trefwoorden | housing policies, education markets, new schools, educational geography, friction costs |
Auteurs | Prof. dr. Sietske Waslander |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
While international research gives increasing attention to geographical factors in education, this perspective is lacking in Dutch research and policy. That a geographical perspective is badly needed, is demonstrated on the basis of the proposed policy to promote new schools in the Netherlands. Current housing policies for Dutch schools are described, pointing at disputes between municipalities and school boards who hold shared responsibilities. Next, foreign housing policies for new schools are studied, that is for friskolor in Sweden, free schools in England and charter schools in Texas (USA). Experiences abroad not only testify that very different choices can be made, but indicate that housing policies may in the long run have a substantial impact on segregation and educational inequality. It is also shown that new schools are mainly located in urban areas. It is argued that in addition to costs for new schools, friction costs for existing schools need to be considered. In all, a geographical perspective on education is needed, so as to prevent increasing segregation and social inequality as well as wasting public financial resources. |
Artikel |
Sturing van warmtenetten: naar een typologie van governance-structuren van warmte-infrastructuren |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurs­wetenschappen, Aflevering 3 2016 |
Auteurs | Dr. Maurits Sanders, Mr. Anne Veerle Brunnekreef en Prof. mr. dr. Michiel Heldeweg |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
A promising option in energy transition is a more efficient use of heat by linking local heating projects to a regional infrastructure. Although this is technologically feasible and the local officials are often benevolent, such projects only scantily get off the ground. The main challenge appears to be the aspect of the appropriate type of governance for the design and use of regional heat networks. The authors of this article developed a governance-typology for heat networks. The aim of the typology is to help unravel the complexity in the planning of heat infrastructures, taking due account of some legal principles. This typology also enables to categorize heating projects. In this way it is possible to provide some insight in the influence of the stakeholders’ preferences on the governance of heat infrastructures. Barriers and opportunities can be reduced that may hinder or promote the use of waste heat. Local officials may use the information for preventing or breaking through deadlocks in the planning of heat infrastructures. |
Artikel |
Decentrale overheden en beleidsinnovaties ter ondersteuning van actief burgerschap in de productie van lokaal opgewekte duurzame energie |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurs­wetenschappen, Aflevering 3 2016 |
Auteurs | Beau Warbroek MSc en Dr. Thomas Hoppe |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Local authorities know for some time from experience with partnerships with local communities in the area of sustainable development that the urgency of climate change increases and that citizens develop into an equal partner. The convergence of these two motivations asks for an innovative way of acting, in which the performance of local authorities is a crucial factor for the ultimate success of local sustainable energy projects in which citizens are actively involved or will be involved. This article exposes the ways in which local authorities innovate with policy for the support of active citizenship in the production of locally generated sustainable energy. The article also explores the barriers that arise. The authors analyse two cases on different levels of government; ‘The Energy-workplace’ (in the Dutch province Fryslân) and ‘The Armhoede sustainable energy landscape’ (in the Dutch municipality Lochem). The cases show that policy innovations crystallize as well at ‘arm’s length’ distance as in the direct sphere of influence of the (local) authority. However, innovation takes place by the grace of the space in the existing institutional framework and the political (and administrative) system. Formal guidelines (like policy or regulation), persons, and informal practices of the traditional policy implementation may hinder a productive interaction between (active) citizens and government. |
Artikel |
Polycentrisme in lokale besluitvorming over duurzame energie: de casus slimme netten |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurs­wetenschappen, Aflevering 3 2016 |
Auteurs | Imke Lammers MSc en Dr. Maarten Arentsen |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Energy planning and the realization of a new energetic infrastructure has become an issue for many actors. The local setting has become polycentric. Against this background the authors have tried to answer the question of the possible consequences of a polycentric local decision-making arena for the realization of sustainable energy transition, especially the implementation of smart grids. Polycentrism is characterised by configurations of units that are multi-level, multi-purpose, multi-sectoral and multi-functional. The impact of these configurations can be assessed using four criteria: control, efficiency, political representation and local self-determination. The authors used these criteria to analyse two cases. Both cases show that the consequences of polycentrism are variable and differ on the four criteria. The analysis shows tensions in polycentric configurations between control and efficiency on the one hand and local self-determination and political representation on the other. This outcome was a reason for the authors to argue for a better institutional design for the local polycentric arena with the help of the seven ‘rules-in-use’ of Elinor Ostrom. Her design is universal but requires specific local application. In this way more justice can be done to the local circumstances in order to be able to achieve effective results. |
Artikel |
Besluit themanummer ‘Energietransitie en lokaal bestuur’ |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurs­wetenschappen, Aflevering 3 2016 |
Auteurs | Dr. Thomas Hoppe, Prof. dr. Ellen van Bueren en Dr. Maurits Sanders |
Auteursinformatie |
Artikel |
De slag om duurzaamheid in de polycentrische regio’s Randstad en Rijn-Roergebied |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurs­wetenschappen, Aflevering 3 2016 |
Auteurs | Simon Goess MSc, Prof. dr. Ellen van Bueren en Prof. dr. Martin de Jong |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
In polycentric urban regions one can find different, mutually related cities without a clear centre. In these regions cities cooperate to attract inhabitants and employment, but at the same time they are each other’s competitors. The Randstad (Netherlands) and the Rhine-Ruhr area (Germany) both can be seen as polycentric regions. The authors explore to what extent these regions possess a common identity and common agenda and to what extent this promotes the sustainability and energy transition of these regions. In both regions identity appears to have grown especially at subregional level, by historically developed spatial-economic profiles of the different cities or suburban regions. In addition the cities in these regions more and more wish to distinguish themselves in the area of sustainability. Every city wants to be the smartest, greenest and healthiest, and to be at the forefront in energy transition and climate mitigation. In the Dutch Randstad this competitive drive especially seems to contribute to the realization of sustainability projects at the local level. And that is exactly why regional cooperation is important: to allocate resources as well as possible and to avoid transfer to others. This can be improved by the development of subregional or regional sustainability visions. |
Artikel |
|
Tijdschrift | Beleidsonderzoek Online, juli 2016 |
Auteurs | Maarten Hoekstra |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Bij bijvoorbeeld de bouw van een gemeentelijk multifunctioneel centrum of de aanschaf van een nieuw computersysteem wordt bijna standaard om een business case gevraagd, om daarmee een zakelijke rechtvaardiging van de te nemen beslissing te verschaffen: nut en noodzaak moeten goed uit de doeken worden gedaan. Dit artikel presenteert de eerste resultaten van een zoektocht naar de (vermeende) kwaliteiten van dit besluitvormingsinstrument. Als ijkpunt voor het praktische gebruik van de business case wordt een nieuw ideaaltype van de business case geconstrueerd. De bestaande definities bieden daarvoor afzonderlijk onvoldoende houvast. Aan de hand van het ideaalmodel wordt vervolgens onderzocht hoe de business case in het publieke debat wordt gebruikt. Het datamateriaal bestaat uit 244 nieuwsberichten uit binnen- en buitenland over uiteenlopende business cases. Het artikel laat zien dat de business case sterk in opkomst is en zijn weg vindt in een divers palet van maatschappelijke thema’s en sectoren. Kwalitatieve argumenten voeren sterk de boventoon ten opzichte van cijfermatige inzichten. De belangrijkste kracht van de business case in het publieke domein ligt in het gegeven dat zowel de belangen van initiatiefnemers en bestuurders als van andere stakeholders worden benoemd. |
Artikel |
|
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 2 2016 |
Trefwoorden | Public Administration, Policy Sciences, Academia vs. practice |
Auteurs | Dr. Philip Marcel Karré |
Samenvatting |
For this article, part of a series on the future of the discipline in the Netherlands, the author has talked to ten newly appointed professors in the field of public administration. We discussed their background, how they see their role and position within university and society and how they view recent developments in our field of study and our discipline. The young professors share their view on how our discipline could and should develop and what their role will be in this process. |
Artikel |
Waarom evalueren beleidsmakers?Een longitudinale analyse van motieven voor beleidsevaluatie in Vlaamse ministeriële beleidsnota’s |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 2 2016 |
Trefwoorden | policy evaluation, evaluation purposes, Flanders, document analysis, evaluation discourse |
Auteurs | Drs. Bart De Peuter en Dr. Valérie Pattyn |
Samenvatting |
The evaluation purpose is decisive for how a policy evaluation is eventually used and deserves more attention in policy evaluation studies. In the present article, we investigated the motives underpinning concrete evaluations, as outlined in four series of Flemish ministerial policy notes that altogether span a 20-year policy period. The most important key finding is that the evaluation purposes are not sensitive to certain modes, neither are they strongly influenced by reforms and corresponding discourse. Despite the introduction of New Public Management oriented reforms in the Flemish public sector and the financial crisis, the relative share of attention that each of the evaluation purposes get has remained relatively unchanged across time. There seems to be a stable demand for ex ante and ex post evaluations and associated evaluation purposes. The common perception of a trend towards ever more evidence-based policy can hence not be confirmed. Remarkable as well is the low share of attention given to ‘accountability’, at least in discourse. |
Artikel |
Evaluatievermogen bij beleidsdepartementenLessen uit praktijken rond planning, uitvoering en gebruik van beleidsevaluaties |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 2 2016 |
Trefwoorden | evaluation capacity, policy evaluation, evaluation process, evaluation use |
Auteurs | Dr. Carolien M. Klein Haarhuis en Dr. Andreea Parapuf |
Samenvatting |
In this article, we explore how evaluations are managed by Dutch policy departments in terms of six aspects of evaluation capacity: institutions, programming, budgeting, evaluation process and content, and finally, evaluation use. We also sketch how international organisations and a number of larger countries deal with these issues of evaluation capacity. Internationally, a variety of norms, checklists and procedures demonstrate that the commissioning party is considered to play a key role in the realisation of evaluations as well as their use. Here, evaluation and evaluation knowledge are often viewed as part of the policy process rather than as a separate exercise. Our description of evaluation practices in Dutch policy departments reveals that several capacity-enhancing initiatives were developed in the past few years, such as new evaluation institutions or structures and programs to promote the commissioning of effectiveness evaluations. It also suggests, however, that accountability is an important driving force behind evaluation, perhaps more powerful than learning. |
Artikel |
Beleidsevaluatie, kennis en politiek: nieuw optimisme rond klassieke paradoxen |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 2 2016 |
Auteurs | Dr. Peter van der Knaap en Dr. Valérie Pattyn |
Artikel |
Probleemanalyse is het halve werkSamenwerking en innovatie in de strijd tegen ondermijnende criminaliteit |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurs­wetenschappen, Aflevering 2 2016 |
Auteurs | Maurits Waardenburg BSc, Bas Keijser BSc, Prof. dr. Martijn Groenleer e.a. |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Science and practice are largely agreed on the importance of interorganizational cooperation in the approach of tackling complex societal problems. Organization transcending innovation through this type of cooperation however appears to be complicated. Based on an analysis of the literature about partnerships, the authors distinguish three challenges: coping with the tension between old and new accountability structures, building good working relationships and developing capabilities for problem-oriented working. Starting from these insights they designed action research into problem-oriented partnerships in the safety domain (safety chain). Their main question was: what is the most important obstacle for innovation through problem-oriented interorganizational cooperation? Over a period of nine months, they watched eight teams of professionals from different organizations. Their task was to develop and implement innovative approaches to tackle persistent organized crime. Although all three challenges identified in the literature indeed played a prominent role, problem diagnosis and problem definition appeared to be the main obstacle for the teams. In this article the authors describe the action research and explore, on the basis of the results and the literature, how partnerships could cope in practice with the challenge of problem definition and problem analysis. They conclude the article with suggestions for the design of a follow-up round of the action research. |
Artikel |
|
Tijdschrift | Beleidsonderzoek Online, mei 2016 |
Auteurs | André Knottnerus |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Een lerende overheid heeft behoefte aan beleidsevaluaties die niet alleen van betekenis zijn voor het onderwerp waarop deze primair gericht zijn, maar ook bijdragen aan bredere, systematische opbouw van kennis en ervaring. Het interdepartementaal verbinden van expertise verruimt daarbij het zicht op factoren die het leren bevorderen of belemmeren. |
Artikel |
|
Tijdschrift | Beleidsonderzoek Online, februari 2016 |
Auteurs | Maud Stinckens |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
De voorbije vier decennia werden er heel wat studies naar de implementatie van beleid uitgevoerd, maar deze hebben vier belangrijke tekortkomingen: (1) onduidelijke omschrijving van de afhankelijke variabele, (2) te weinig inzicht in de ‘kritieke’ onafhankelijke variabelen en te weinig aandacht voor de wijze waarop deze in combinatie met elkaar het beleidsimplementatieproces beïnvloeden, (3) te laag aantal cases en (4) te weinig aandacht voor hypothesetoetsing. Dit artikel geeft aan hoe het gebruik van Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA) (Ragin, 1987) een antwoord kan bieden op deze beperkingen. Deze analysemethode tracht de verschillende causale paden die het beleidsimplementatieproces beïnvloeden te identificeren en de condities of combinaties van condities die noodzakelijk of voldoende zijn in kaart te brengen. Hiervoor wordt gebruikgemaakt van Booleaanse algebra. Door deze en andere specifieke eigenschappen kan QCA leiden tot vernieuwende inzichten in beleidsimplementatieonderzoek. |
Article |
Naar een voorwaardelijk model van ongelijkheid in vertegenwoordigingEen onderzoek naar het moderatie-effect van beleidsdomeinen op ongelijkheid in beleidscongruentie |
Tijdschrift | Res Publica, Aflevering 1 2016 |
Trefwoorden | Policy congruence, inequality, education, policy domains |
Auteurs | Christophe Lesschaeve |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
This article studies the extent to which differences or inequality in policy congruence between higher and lower educated voters are moderated by policy domains. Instead of measuring inequality across all areas of policy, this study takes a policy domain-specific approach. The analyses are based on a dataset containing voters and party positions on 50 policy statements, gathered in the run-up to the 2009 regional election in Belgium largest region, Flanders. We find, overall, only small and unsubstantial, though significant, differences, in policy congruence between higher and lower educated voters, in favor of the former. However, we find a much larger representational bias towards higher educated when we look at transportation, culture and media, immigration, taxand budgetary policy, and economic policy. At the same time, differences in policy congruence are lower as regards spatial planning. Studying inequality in policy congruence across policy domains thus hides more complex patterns of representational bias. |