The police use all sorts of information to fulfil their tasks. Whereas collection and interpretation of information traditionally could only be done by humans, the emergence of ‘Big Data’ creates new opportunities and dilemmas. On the one hand, large amounts of data can be used to train algorithms. This allows them to ‘predict’ offenses such as bicycle theft, burglary, or even serious crimes such as murder and terrorist attacks. On the other hand, highly relevant questions on purpose, effectiveness, and legitimacy of the application of machine learning/‘artificial intelligence’ drown all too often in the ocean of Big Data. This is particularly problematic if such systems are used in the public sector in democracies, where the rule of law applies, and where accountability, as well as the possibility for judicial review, are guaranteed. In this article, we explore the role transparency could play in reconciling these opportunities and dilemmas. While some propose making the systems and data they use themselves transparent, we submit that an open and broad discussion on purpose and objectives should be held during the design process. This might be a more effective way of embedding ethical and legal principles in the technology, and of ensuring legitimacy during application. |
Thema-artikel |
Een transparant debat over algoritmen |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 4 2020 |
Trefwoorden | AI, ethics, Big Data, human rights, governance |
Auteurs | Dr. Oskar J. Gstrein en Prof. dr. Andrej Zwitter |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Thema-artikel |
Samen wonen om te integrerenHoe gemengde woonprojecten interactie stimuleren tussen vluchtelingen en Nederlandse bewoners |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 3 2020 |
Trefwoorden | refugees, integration, mixed housing projects, collaborative housing, social connections |
Auteurs | Carla Huisman MSc en Dr. Darinka Czischke |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
The integration of refugees in the Netherlands has been suboptimal for years. After receiving a residence permit, refugees are distributed across the country and dispersed over neighborhoods. However, since the 2015 refugee crisis, the municipality of Amsterdam has adopted a different approach. Here, refugees that have been granted residence live together with Dutch young adults in projects where they share facilities and play a role in managing the project. To what extent can such mixed housing projects help the integration of refugees? The Startblok Riekerhaven, which was the first project, was studied for a year with qualitative research. The findings show that mixed housing projects can stimulate the formation of social connections. In this way they can contribute to the integration of refugees in the Netherlands. Given the suboptimal results of the current dispersal policy, this is relevant for science and policy. |
Thema-artikel |
Niet toegeven maar teruggeven bij protestEffecten van beleid bij vestiging van een asielzoekerscentrum in Utrecht |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 3 2020 |
Trefwoorden | asylum seeker centres, local opposition, policy effects, inter-group contact, Utrecht |
Auteurs | Dr. Rianne Dekker, Dr. Karin Geuijen en Dr. Caroline Oliver |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
The refugee crisis of 2015-2016 prompted European governments to quickly institute new asylum seeker centres. Often however, plans for opening new reception centres are met with protest in surrounding localities. Gaining public support for new ASCs has become a pressing governance issue facing local governments. This research looks at whether a policy strategy of ‘giving back’ to the neighbourhood rather than ‘giving in’ to the demands of protesters can minimise local opposition and alleviate negative attitudes . A door-to-door survey of N = 511 neighbourhood residents is combined with semi-structured interview data of N = 31 neighbourhood residents. We find that attitudes were already neutral to fairly positive shortly after the centre opened and fears of nuisance and crime did not materialise. Those who became involved in the ASCs’ courses and activities are a small and selective group who were already fairly accepting of the centre. Contact between asylum seekers and neighbours developing within and beyond the ASC was valued but did not develop into stronger ties due to frequent moves of asylum seekers and early closure of the ASC. |
Thema-artikel |
Spreidingsbeleid voor huisvesting van statushoudersSpeelt de buurt een rol in de vroege integratie? |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 3 2020 |
Trefwoorden | social integration, contact, refugees, neighborhood diversity, dispersion policy |
Auteurs | Dr. Meta van der Linden |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
The Netherlands has been struggling with the question of how to facilitate the integration of refugees who crossed into Europe during the 2015/2016 ‘refugee crisis’. Dutch municipalities aim for the dispersion of refugees over various neighborhoods under the assumption that the ethnic composition of the neighborhood is conducive to integration. In the current study, I test this assumption using a new and representative survey (N = 768 predominantly Syrian refugees living in 45 neighborhoods, response rate 85%) linked to neighborhood data situated in the most ethnically diverse city in the Netherlands; Rotterdam. Multilevel analyses revealed that, generally, a larger share of people without a migration background in the neighborhood was related to more frequent contact with neighbors without a migration background. A larger share of people with a Moroccan background was related to more frequent contact with people with a Moroccan background, but predominantly for Syrian refugees. The neighborhood was not related to contact with people from the same background of with people with a Turkish background. Hence, meeting opportunities in the neighborhood only appear to facilitate social integration if they coincide with refugees’ social preferences. |
Thema-artikel |
Van diversiteitsagenda’s tot participatietrajectenEen vergelijking van lokaal vluchtelingenbeleid in zestien Nederlandse gemeenten |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 3 2020 |
Trefwoorden | local governance, decentralization, refugees, immigrant integration, mainstreaming |
Auteurs | Ilona van Breugel MSc |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
This article describes the main trends in refugee policies in sixteen Dutch cities, offering an overview of the local approaches to the reception, housing and integration of refugees that the cities rapidly had to develop in response to the increased refugee inflow in 2015. In contrast to other studies that often focus on capital and gateway cities, this article illustrates the variety of local approaches to migration diversity and refugee integration. By illustrating the different positions municipalities take, the article shows the local power to innovate. In this article clusters of cities with comparable approaches to refugee policies are identified to aid cooperation and knowledge exchange between cities, in which the big cities are not necessarily always the relevant partners. |
Vrij artikel |
Autonomie ontrafeld. De casus van de Nederlandse Kinderombudsman |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 2 2020 |
Trefwoorden | autonomy, ombudsperson, children’s ombudsman, national ombudsman, Paris Principles |
Auteurs | Marjolein Bouterse MSc en Dr. Valérie Pattyn |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
A key factor to a well-functioning ombudsman’s office is autonomy, which can also be derived from the public turmoil surrounding the appointment of Dutch Children’s ombudsman in 2016. Organization-wise, the Dutch Children’s ombudsman is embedded within an existing autonomous institution: the National ombudsman. This triggers the question to what extent such nested constructions can guarantee sufficient autonomy. Viewing the statutory and de facto autonomy of the Children’s ombudsman, we find that the autonomy of the Children’s ombudsman depends to a large extent on the position of the National ombudsman and on the relationship between the National ombudsman and the Children’s ombudsman. Our findings point out that it is necessary to determine and codify the degree of autonomy at the start of an ombudsman’s office. |
Thema-artikel |
Succesvol wethouderschap onder de loepBronnen van legitimiteit in de ogen van inwoners, raadsleden en wethouders |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 2 2020 |
Trefwoorden | Aldermen, Local government, Success, Politics, Legitimacy |
Auteurs | Drs. Peter Verheij |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
Research into successful alderman is scarce. Scientifically less is known about the perspective of residents and council members on (successful) aldermen. A recent study investigated the sources of legitimacy that successful aldermen draw on. In addition, the contribution of characteristics of local political leadership to successful alderman has been examined. Based on a survey of residents, councilors and aldermen, differences in opinions about aldermen, aspects and indicators of legitimacy and personal characteristics were uncovered. There are clear differences in judgment, indicators and personal characteristics that are considered important and another source on which the judgment is based. This provides interesting and new research material for public administration literature as well as for administrative practice. The view of residents learns us that the distance to aldermen must be reduced, more connection must be made, a more outside view must be taken and an addition to the management style of councilors with responsive qualities is required. |
Thema-artikel |
|
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 2 2020 |
Trefwoorden | municipal secretary, aldermen, authority, local governance, sources of legitimacy |
Auteurs | Drs. Thijs Jansen en Corné van der Meulen MSc |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
When we look at the number of people leaving local governance, we see a discouraging trend. According to an investigation of the magazine Binnenlands Bestuur, 126 of 1144 aldermen in the Netherlands were forced to step down in 2019. Making 2019 the year with the highest number since 2004. The same trend can be seen with municipal secretaries. A municipal secretary used to be a lifetime appointment, yet now they often stay at their position for no more than 5 years. |
Vrij artikel |
20 jaar Verantwoordingsdag: Inzicht voor KamercommissiesHoe inhoudsanalyse inzicht geeft in prestatiegegevensgebruik door Kamerleden |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 1 2020 |
Trefwoorden | performance information, accountability, Parliament, annual reports, Performance-based Budgeting |
Auteurs | Dr. Sjoerd Keulen |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
The 20th Accountability Day of the Netherlands House of Representatives is a fitting occasion to investigate whether Dutch Members of Parliament use performance information (PI). Performance information used by managers and politicians is a basic assumption for managing and guiding Performance-based Budgeting. Ironically, based on a literature review on performance use, we know that politicians and especially parliamentarians do not use performance information for decision making or scrutiny. This is specifically so when PI reports are long. Using the framework of accountability of Bovens (2007) and using content analysis of the questions, motions and debates of the Standing Committees on the annual reports, this article shows that MPs use performance information in all phases (informing, debating, sanctions). Contradicting earlier research on parliamentarians, we found that they use annual reports and reports of the Court of Audit as their main sources in the debates. This article shows that the use of PI in parliament is steadily rising. The growing importance of performance information for accountability is further illustrated by the strengthening of the accountability forum. |
Vrij artikel |
Weinig consistent, beperkt zelfkritischDe uitwerking van de beleidsconclusie binnen de rijksverantwoording |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 4 2019 |
Trefwoorden | accountability, policy evaluation, policy conclusion |
Auteurs | Bram Faber MA en Dr. Tjerk Budding |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
The Dutch central government has a long history in its search to meaningfully present policy effects. One of the instruments that was developed to this end is the Policy Conclusion (beleidsconclusie). This part of the annual report, which has been mandatory since 2013, should provide a judgement for every policy article on its results in the year 2017. To what extent has the Policy Conclusion been successful in its aims? And how do various governmental departments give substance to it? For this article, all policy conclusions that were composed for the most recent reporting year were examined. Among others, our analysis shows that departments differ greatly in their interpretation of what the Policy Conclusion should include, such as the usage of sources and the way in which intended results are (re)addressed. In addition, it was found in the Policy Conclusions that a tendency exists to put a strong focus on positive outcomes. |
Thema-artikel |
Van procedure naar praktijkInzet op effectieve onafhankelijkheidsborging bij het Planbureau voor de Leefomgeving |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 4 2019 |
Trefwoorden | policy research organizations, research independence, political pressure, coping strategies, independence safeguards |
Auteurs | Dr. Femke Verwest, Dr. Eva Kunseler, Dr. Paul Diederen e.a. |
SamenvattingAuteursinformatie |
If the stakes are high, policy researchers can find themselves under strong pressures from politicians or policy makers to compromise on issues like scope of a research project, research methodology, reporting, framing and interpretation of results, and timing of publication. Research organizations experiment with various formal and informal arrangements to cope with such pressures and guard their independence. |
Thema-artikel |
‘Meedoen is belangrijker dan winnen’Prijzen als exponent van de positieve bestuurskunde? |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 3 2019 |
Trefwoorden | Positive Public Administration, prizes, successes |
Auteurs | Dr. Tom Overmans, Prof. dr. Mirko Noordegraaf en Prof. dr. Filip De Rynck |
Samenvatting |
Positive Public Administration (PPA) encourages scholars to examine governance success. The appreciation of successes, however, is not new. During previous decades, awards were bestowed for exceptional performance. We analyse whether two important awards in the Netherlands and Flanders are an expression of PPA. Firstly, we find that successes are interpreted differently: in the Netherlands, one-off, trendy performances are rewarded, while in Flanders the focus is on consolidated results of long-term change processes. Secondly, we see that ‘clean’ success criteria promote a suggestion of ‘control’, whilst public settings are ambiguous and unpredictable. Finally, we conclude that prizes are primarily celebrations; little evidence is found of systematic knowledge exchange, learning and professionalisation. |
Vrij artikel |
Paradox van het Pact van de WaardDynamische regionale samenwerking in een krimpende Hoeksche Waard |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 3 2019 |
Trefwoorden | shrinking regions, regime theory, population decline, regional collaboration, regional strategies |
Auteurs | Janneke Rutgers-Zoet Msc en Dr. Tamara Metze |
Samenvatting |
In several regions in the Netherlands there are declining population numbers. In those regions, administrators, companies and societal organisations often start regional collaborations in order to anticipate population decline and maintain a good quality of life. This is a logical step, but in practice the collaborating partners face challenges. For this article we analysed over a period of eight years the dynamics of cooperation in the Hoeksche Waard, a region in the province of South Holland that is dealing with a decrease in the number of inhabitants. On the basis of the regime model (Stone 1989), and by conducting qualitative research, in this exploratory study we discerned a paradox of regional cooperation in this ‘shrinking’ region: a decline of population numbers is the reason to initiate informal cooperation in networks, but the complexity of the regional agenda leads to the desire for formalisation of the collaborations in formal decision making structures. This formalisation, in its turn, leads to less commitment from the parties and makes cooperation and achieving results difficult, which increases the need for informalisation. |
Thema-artikel ‘Uitgesproken Bestuurskunde’ |
Europese regelgeving: meer dan de som der delen? |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 2 2019 |
Trefwoorden | European Union, EU legislation, evaluation, implementation, European administrative networks |
Auteurs | Prof. dr. Ellen Mastenbroek |
Samenvatting |
Evaluations of EU legislation can fulfill a key role in the European policy process. They can provide the knowledge base required for political accountability towards the electorate, and form a basis for the improvement of existing legislation. This article introduces a research agenda in the realm of the ex-post evaluation of EU legislation, which comprises two research lines. The first strand comprises research into ex post legislative evaluations conducted by the European Commission. This research is innovative, because EU policy researchers so far have barely touched upon evaluation, as a final and important stage in the EU policy cycle. By assessing evaluation critically, we can ascertain to what extent the EU’s ex-post evaluation system is more than an instrument, aimed at increasing the EU’s legitimacy. The second research strand is own evaluation research, focusing on the role of European administrative networks- intergovernmental structures that have been established to improve the implementation of EU legislation by the member states. By critically evaluating the functioning and effectiveness of these networks, I hope to be able to find out whether and under what conditions these network structures are more, than the sum of their national parts. |
Thema-artikel ‘Uitgesproken Bestuurskunde’ |
Bestuurswetenschap in de kennissamenlevingEen pleidooi voor een transdisciplinaire en veelvormige wetenschapsbenadering |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 2 2019 |
Trefwoorden | research program, knowledge society, transdisciplinarity, plural approach, technology |
Auteurs | Prof. dr. Albert Meijer |
Samenvatting |
This article presents the research program into governance in a knowledge society of professor Albert Meijer and colleagues at Utrecht University. The knowledge society is a society in which (1) citizens are higher educated that ever before and their level of education largely determines their societal position, (2) knowledge plays a key role in administrative and policy processes and is increasingly contested and (3) technology plays a key role in every facet of societal life. Research into governance of and in the knowledge society requires a transdisciplinary and plural approach to scientific work. Transdisciplinarity entails combining insights from science with various forms of contextual and practical knowledge. A plural approach to scientific works means that we should not only do explanatory empirical work but also theoretical, normative and prescriptive research. The overall ambition of this research program is to contribute to a democratic debate about the governance of the future. |
Thema-artikel ‘Uitgesproken Bestuurskunde’ |
Toezicht en governance in de open samenleving |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 2 2019 |
Trefwoorden | corporate crime, Governance, Enforcement, Regulation, public administration |
Auteurs | Prof. dr. Judith van Erp |
Samenvatting |
Regulation and markets have become central steering mechanisms in modern states, but have received relatively little attention in public administration. This contribution argues that questions around regulation, monitoring and enforcement deserve more attention in public administration scholarship. It sketches the development of ‘Regulatory Governance’ as a scholarly field, and discusses the added value of a criminological perspective on relations between state and market. A research agenda on ‘naming and shaming’ brings these perspectives together. |
Thema-artikel |
‘Macho-meritocratie’ SingaporeVijf lessen uit het genadeloze streven naar ambtelijke excellentie |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 1 2019 |
Trefwoorden | Singapore, public service excellence, Performance, comparative public administration |
Auteurs | Prof. dr. Zeger van der Wal |
Samenvatting |
Singapore and the Netherlands are small, export- and trade-dependent countries that perform excellently in many areas, such as good governance and integrity, policy effectiveness, liveability, innovation, and e-government. At the same time there are clear differences in political culture and history: Singapore has a more authoritarian governance style including limitations in press freedom, freedom of speech, and political activism. Within these contrasting contexts, both countries have introduced and implemented similar public management reforms since the 1990s. The aim of these reforms is to maintain public service excellence in a dynamic environment but the countries make contrasting choices in achieving this aim. This article describes how administrative excellence is organised and pursued in Singapore and identifies five lessons for the Netherlands: (1) Use positive narratives about government often; (2) be nuanced about capping top-level remuneration; (3) enhance the attractiveness of government as an employer; (4) invest in life-long learning; (5) be an authoritative expert amidst horizontalisation hypes. |
Thema-artikel |
Strategische planning en fusies in Vlaamse gemeentenEen essay over Vlaamse ervaringen met New Public Management-hervormingen |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 1 2019 |
Trefwoorden | new public management, local government, strategic planning, municipal mergers, Flemish municipalities |
Auteurs | Bert George PhD |
Samenvatting |
In the past years, Flemish municipalities have been confronted with a plethora of new public management reforms. The two probably most salient reforms include the introduction of a strategic planning system entitled the policy and management cycle (PMC) as well as the provision of financial incentives for municipalities that undertake a merger. These reforms are not unique to the Flemish context. Indeed, similar reforms took place in the Netherlands, where policy and management instruments (PMI) – a strategic planning system – were introduced in the eighties and municipal mergers have been part of the political agenda for several decades. But similar reforms also took place in, for instance, the United Kingdom (i.e. the best value regime in 1999) as well as Denmark (i.e. the municipal mergers in 2007). In this essay, these Flemish reforms are critically evaluated, taking into account following question: which public values are triggered through these reforms, and what might this imply for the Flemish and Dutch local public sector? This essay uses new public governance principles such as strategic thinking and the learning organisation to answer this question. |
Thema-artikel |
Voortvarend in verbouwenHoe Denemarken efficiënt drastische beleidswijzigingen realiseert (maar niet per se heel effectief blijkt) |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 1 2019 |
Trefwoorden | Comparative public administration, Public reform, Reform implementation, Decentralisation, Civil service |
Auteurs | Eline van Schaik MSc |
Samenvatting |
In international comparative research, a dominant image often emerges of Denmark as a frontrunner in innovative governance, gaining top results in international rankings. |
Vrij artikel |
Transparantie in de EU-RaadOnvermijdelijk en onmisbaar? Onverzadelijk en onuitvoerbaar? |
Tijdschrift | Bestuurskunde, Aflevering 1 2019 |
Trefwoorden | transparency, Council of the EU, access to documents, democratic legitimacy |
Auteurs | Dr. Maarten Hillebrandt |
Samenvatting |
The democratic deficit is generally observed to be one of the largest challenges facing the European Union. This is in spite of the fact that the member states introduced transparency in 1992 to address this legitimacy problem. This article asks why, after several decades, the transparency policy has still not delivered on its promise. In doing so, it bases itself on new empirical data that was collected in the context of a recently presented dissertation (Hillebrandt, 2017), while drawing a strict distinction between the empirical policy change question and the normative desirability question. From a longitudinal comparative analysis, a differentiated empirical image arises. On the one hand, a clear enhancement of legislative transparency can be discerned; on the other hand, a plurality of transparency-evasive practices has emerged in the area of non-legislative decision-making. This equivocal image supports contrasting normative responses, according to which transparency is respectively cast as an indispensable ideal, a fiction, or a solution in search of a problem. |